The recent unveiling of a new form of drug testing has sparked renewed conversation about the uses and challenges of workplace drug policy. Oral-fluid testing—a method that detects marijuana and other substances using saliva—has advantages and disadvantages relative to more established collection methods such as urine or blood testing. The emergence of this testing method highlights broader questions about how and why organizations implement drug testing in the workplace.
While drug testing policies are often associated with industries that involve hazardous equipment or dynamic environments, even mission-driven organizations such as nonprofits may find that some level of accountability is necessary for safety, compliance, or values-based reasons. Whether you’re drafting a new policy or reviewing an existing one, it’s important to ensure it aligns with both your organizational goals and current federal and state laws. It’s equally important to weigh how such a policy could affect your recruitment, retention, and organizational culture.
Start with Clear Goals
Drug testing should never be implemented in a vacuum. Many organizations begin testing without a clear understanding of what they’re trying to accomplish. Setting specific goals allows you to measure impact, communicate transparently with employees, and select an approach that aligns with your organizational values. Common goals include:
- Safety: In safety-sensitive environments, drug testing programs have shown some success in reducing workplace accidents. This is particularly relevant for organizations where employees operate machinery or work in high-risk settings.
- Compliance: Organizations that work with government partners or manage regulated services may be required to implement testing as part of federal or state compliance standards—especially when data, transportation, or security are involved.
- Organizational Values: For mission-driven nonprofits, policies may align with their core values. A nonprofit working in addiction recovery, for example, may choose to uphold a drug-free environment as part of its commitment to the people it serves.
- Risk Management: Drug use has been linked to higher rates of absenteeism, turnover, and health issues, which can affect organizational performance. While the evidence is mixed, some nonprofits view testing as a way to manage these risks—particularly if they already struggle with retention.
Understand Your Testing Options
Drug testing isn’t one-size-fits-all. There are multiple testing schedules and specimen types to consider, each with different implications for cost, invasiveness, and effectiveness. Here are common scheduling options:
- Pre-employment
- Post-incident
- Scheduled
- Random
- For cause
Testing methods include urine, blood, hair, and oral-fluid collection. Each has trade-offs. For example, blood and urine tests can detect usage over longer periods, but may be seen as more invasive. Oral-fluid testing detects recent use and is generally less invasive, making it more suitable when real-time impairment is the concern.
Consider Organizational Impacts
Even when drug testing is well-intentioned, it can affect employee morale, especially in sectors where the link between safety and substance use is less direct. Communication is key—employees need to understand the why behind your policy and how it supports your mission and workplace environment.
This issue becomes even more complex in states where marijuana is decriminalized or approved for medical use. Employees may view testing as an infringement on their personal rights, particularly if it extends beyond working hours or doesn’t account for legal use.
Seek Expert Guidance
Developing or updating a drug testing policy is not a simple undertaking. It involves legal considerations, cultural awareness, and operational alignment. If you’re evaluating your current approach—or considering whether testing is appropriate at all—expert support can help you navigate these decisions thoughtfully.
About Us
For more than 40 years, 501(c) Services has been a leader in offering solutions for unemployment costs, claims management, and HR support to nonprofit organizations. Two of our most popular programs are the 501(c) Agencies Trust and 501(c) HR Services. We understand the importance of compliance and accuracy and are committed to providing our clients with customized plans that fit their needs.
Contact us today to see if your organization could benefit from our services.
Are you already working with us and need assistance with an HR or unemployment issue? Contact us here.
